Evidencing Value Creation
Why will your customer sign an outcome-led contract? Cross the line.
Outcome-led contracts are worth more revenue, more margin and a longer term to the supplier. But a contract needs two signatures. The customer signs when the supplier crosses the line — and works on the customer's operating cost. That is where the gold is.
George Davies · 26 October 2026 · 9 min read
The view from the supplier's side of the line
From its own side, a supplier sees its fee. Every renewal is an argument about it.
Take a people-intensive operation in an illustrative model, built on published UK benchmarks. The customer spends £12.1m a year to run it: payroll, employer on-costs, overtime, recruitment, staff turnover and estate. The supplier's fee is £252,000. Two per cent.
2%
The supplier's fee as a share of what the customer spends running the operation. Take 10% off the fee and the customer saves £25,200. The value sits in the other 98%.
Most suppliers do not realise how marginal they are. The value sits on the customer's side of the line, and most suppliers have never looked at it.
“When a portco CEO tells the board that clients are not asking to change the pricing model, the IC hears something else. They hear a management team that cannot quantify its own value creation.”
What keeps suppliers on their side
Input-led contracts. Paid per seat, per user or per day, the supplier is paid to keep the customer's operating cost where it is. Every efficiency it finds removes units the customer stops paying for. So nobody inside the contract is paid to go after the 98%.
“As the IT leader signing the vendor contracts, day-rate pricing always put me in the business of managing someone else's utilization instead of my own outcomes.”
Why it cannot wait
AI is eating input-led operating models. Agents resolve cases, build quotes and reconcile invoices. Customers know it, and they expect the work to cost less. Under an input-led contract, that saving arrives as a smaller invoice for the supplier and a small cut to a 2% line for the customer.
12–15% → 34%
Share of financial services AI spend on outcome- or value-based pricing today, versus expected within two years (HFS Research with Capgemini).
The most common reason buyers hold back is that the outcome cannot be defined, measured or tracked. That is a problem the supplier can solve, once it crosses the line.
Cross the line
Crossing the line means understanding the customer's operating environment: the work, the people who do it, what each unit of work costs, where work fails first time and comes back, and what drives the cost. Then committing to bring that cost down and being paid when it falls.
In the model, with the supplier working on the customer's side of the line, roughly a quarter of the work comes out of human handling and more of the rest is resolved first time. The team the customer needs falls from 300 people to 221.
£12.11m → £8.92m
Customer operating cost per year: £3.19m, 26% lower. The customer keeps about three quarters of that saving.
“If you have joint discussions with key stakeholders on which levers really move their numbers, where you can contribute and where you cannot, and which risks each side carries, and these discussions are concluded, the contract is mostly writing it down.”
That is why the customer signs. A supplier paid per seat is paid to keep its operating cost where it is. A supplier on an outcome-led contract is paid to bring it down.
The five questions its finance director will ask
Once you are on the customer's side of the line, its finance director will test the offer with five questions. You can answer them because you are working in its numbers.
1. “Will it cost us more than today?”
“The big problem with switching to value pricing is corporate procurement departments are built to reject it because they only know how to compare simple numbers on a spreadsheet.”
So give them the simple number: the total cost of the service today, under a repriced input contract, and under the outcome-led contract. In the model, after paying the supplier, the customer's total cost of the service falls 19%. Compare the total, never the fee.
2. “What is the most we could pay?”
“The cap feels like a key part of the negotiation for an outcome-based contract... the client will want to incentivise behaviours that drive business benefit for them whilst not opening themselves up to paying a great deal more than they would have, had the contract been a well-delivered T&M one.”
Agree a base fee that covers the service, and a share of the saving that tapers as the saving grows, so the more the customer saves, the larger its own share. The customer knows the most it could pay before it signs. Outcome fees fall due only once the saving is verified, so they are paid out of money the customer has already saved.
3. “How do we know you moved it?”
This is the question that decides whether the other four answers hold, and the one most suppliers cannot answer. The customer's numbers move for many reasons: volume, seasonality, the mix of work, changes to its own products, other suppliers. That distance, between what the service delivered and what can be proved, is the Attribution Gap.
Closing it takes a starting point signed into the contract, from the customer's own data, and a measure that does not move on its own: cost per unit of work, not total cost. If volume falls 10% because the customer's own product improved, total cost falls by about £1.15m with nobody doing anything, while cost per unit of work barely moves. It also means an open book — the term customers hesitate over, and the one the measure cannot do without.
“The tricky part of the outcome model is agreeing the baseline upfront... without a measured “before”, there is nothing to prove the “after” against.”
4. “Is the split fair?”
A 2023 study of 437 professional B2B buyers found that fairness, not risk, decides whether they accept a share of the savings. Offered a 50/50 split with no fixed fee, they were less willing to switch. Offered a fixed fee plus a 75/25 split in their favour, they were more willing, even where the 50/50 deal paid them more. In the model, the customer keeps between 70% and 75% of the value in every case.
5. “What happens if it does not work?”
“I would then test who controls the outcome, when payment becomes due and what happens if the client changes its operations.”
Outcome fees are paid only on a verified saving. Even the model's low case cuts about 12% from the customer's total cost of the service. The agreement signs in two stages: a fixed-fee diagnostic first, then the starting point. Treat the first measurement window as shared discovery, with no penalties attached. A performance bonus tied to quality, not cost, protects the service while the cost falls.
What makes it hold
Every one of the five answers rests on proof. A customer will let a supplier work on its side of the line only if both sides trust the numbers. Without proof, every fee becomes a negotiation. Outcome Engineering enables a service-centric business to define, quantify and prove the impact of its services on the customer's business, in four steps.
- 1
Define
Agree with the customer the outcomes that matter — cost per unit of work, first-time resolution, retention, revenue. Build the starting point from its own data and sign it into the contract.
- 2
Quantify
Build the line of sight from inputs to outcomes, mapping which activities drive cost per unit of work, resolution and rework. In the model, cost per unit of work falls from £3.92 to £3.18. Agree a fair share before the work begins.
- 3
Prove
Attribute the result: show which interventions moved it, separated from volume, seasonality and other outside effects, so the supplier is credited only for the change it drove.
- 4
Recognise
Monitor the outcomes continuously and report them in the customer's own numbers, so the evidence is there at every review and the agreed share is paid without argument.
Get any of the four wrong and the contract becomes an argument. Get all four right and the fee is a calculation.
Where to start
Pick one customer: one where you already hold the data, and where a sponsor owns the budget line and wants the outcome. Cross the line on that account first. Learn its operating environment, agree the starting point, and take the five answers to its finance director in its own numbers.